Smoked pastrami recipe that is sure to impress your guests (2024)

Smoked pastrami recipe that is sure to impress your guests

Gary Jacobson-04/05/2017-Cooking-11 Comments-Backyard BBQ / Cooking BBQ / Other Smoked Meats Recipes

Smoked pastrami recipe that is sure to impress your guests (1)

By Bryan Gooding

It was more than two years ago when the Posse heard a rumor that Cattleack Barbecue in Far North Dallas was going to be serving smoked pastrami for its Saturday special.

I remember thinking “Wow! This is different!” Pitmaster Todd David would be cooking “outside the box.” Afterward I told Posse co-founder Gary Jacobson that Cattleack had thrown down the gauntlet with its smoked pastrami and that there would be a lot of pitmasters experimenting with recipes over the next year. The times were ripe for some new barbecue.

In the fall of 2015 Gary and I cooked at the Blues, Bandits and BBQ event in Oak Cliff, Texas. We always liked to present something different for the crowd and decided to try the pastrami recipe I had been working on. I was happy with what we served and it definitely impressed the tasters, especially once they learned about how long the process takes to produce a smoked pastrami. It is loooooow and sloooooow.

The smoked pastrami recipe

Brine Ingredients:
1 gallon cold water
½ cup salt
1 cup brown sugar
4 tsps Prague salt or pink curing salt
2 tsps cayenne pepper
2 Tbsp coriander seed
2 Tbsp mustard seed
2 Tbsp black peppercorns (whole)
6 cloves garlic (smashed)

Rub Ingredients:
2 tsp chipotle powder
1 cup brown sugar
½ cup kosher salt
½ cup black pepper (cracked or coarse ground)
2 Tbsp mustard seed
¼ cup stone ground mustard

Smoked pastrami recipe that is sure to impress your guests (2)

Brining Process

I’m used to brining chicken and ribs but doing it to beef was new for me. In the deli culture, brining beef has been done for decades. I usually look for a six to seven pound brisket flat. You can use a whole brisket but remember you are then making eleven pounds of pastrami. So I keep things reasonable and just do the flat. If you are making sandwiches the flat will serve about 15 people.

Thoroughly clean the beef, trimming off any silverskin and leaving ¼-inch thickness of fat and set aside.

Mix the brine ingredients in a large plastic type tub with a lid that seals. Prague salt is available at some grocery stores and I found mine on Amazon.

Combine brine ingredients and add extra water if necessary so that meat is totally submerged. The brine is flexible to your taste, some reduce salt and boost sugar since the Prague salt also adds saltiness. Some boost the heat factor or reduce it.

Once you’ve added the meat to the brine, seal and refrigerate. We have a fridge in the garage. I leave it in there to brine for two weeks (good) or three weeks (mo’ better).

Once the meat is brined thoroughly rinse in cold water and pat dry. At this point, you can freeze the flat until you have an event you want to smoke it for.

Cooking Process

When you are ready to cook, and with a thawed flat, rub the meat with stone ground mustard. This acts as an adhesive for the spice rub and the mustard is an excellent base for the flavor.

Smoked pastrami recipe that is sure to impress your guests (3)Next mix the components of your rub, again personalizing to your own taste. Go light on the salt since there was plenty in the brine. In my case I like a sweeter, peppery rub and I enhance the traditional deli taste of the pastrami by using mustard seed and some ground coriander in the rub. Rub both sides of your brisket.

When starting your smoker use a chimney with a little charcoal and a page of newspaper to light. Lighter fluid will flavor your meat so avoid.

Now comes another opportunity to personalize your pastrami in the choice of the wood you use to smoke. Because I live in the Pacific NW, I have to rely on apple or alder whereas in Dallas I loved pecan. Each wood has its own unique character and flavor profile so choose accordingly.

I lay the wood on the charcoal and get the wood burning to the point the charcoal is gone, then I add the flat to the cooking grate.

Add wood or adjust air flow as needed. Try to keep the temperature of the smoker at 200 degrees F. I use a probe thermometer centered in the thickest part of the flat and aim for a target of 185 degrees internal temp. The beef is brined so it is hard to cook it dry.

A general rule of thumb is a hour per pound but there are so many variables this is only a starting point. Some cooks wrap their meat at a certain point in butcher paper. Check out Marshall Cooper’s excellent article here on the Posse site for more info on that.

The key is low and slow.

When your flat reaches the magic number pull and wrap in foil. It is important for the meat to rest as it allows the moisture to move back into the flat and stay juicy. Many pitmasters simply wrap in foil and drop into an empty ice chest until needed, which could be 2 – 3 hours.

Serving

When serving, it is important to slice against the grain. In the case of sandwiches, slice thin. Tell your guests that you’ve been working on this pastrami for three weeks. They’ll think you worked even harder than you did on this great smoked pastrami recipe.

Smoked pastrami recipe that is sure to impress your guests (4)

[/ffb_param][/ffb_paragraph_0]


Smoked pastrami recipe that is sure to impress your guests (5)

bob gorrell

6 years ago

Hello , my question is I have a brisket in the brine , 5 days now, do I set it and forget it till the three week window, or do I rotate it/ swrill the brine? ( thoughts that me keep up at night)

Smoked pastrami recipe that is sure to impress your guests (6)

Bryan Gooding

6 years ago

I like to visit the brisket every couple of days to check in and be a nurturing kind of cook. I few words and a flip makes it feel loved and appreciated plus keeps the juices mixed in the brine.

Smoked pastrami recipe that is sure to impress your guests (7)

BG

6 years ago

got it, thanks this is the longest 3 weeks EVER!!!!!

Smoked pastrami recipe that is sure to impress your guests (8)

bob gorrell

6 years ago

so i am at the 3 week ppint. just want to. check in and male sure i just dry it rub it and smoke it. no steaming involved for this process? Wish me luck!

Smoked pastrami recipe that is sure to impress your guests (9)

James Rojas

6 years ago

How did this turn out? I have been wanting to master the art of Texas smoked pastrami since eating the amazing pastrami at Pieous in Austin. I would love to hear how the pastrami turned out with this recipe. It seems like a great starting point.

Smoked pastrami recipe that is sure to impress your guests (10)

Bryan Gooding

6 years ago

We made some fab sandwiches - the brine made the meat especially juicy - we're having a big party in June and this is on the menu - can't miss

Smoked pastrami recipe that is sure to impress your guests (11)

James Rojas

6 years ago

Thanks for the update. I am looking to learn this and thought this recipe would be a great start. I want to use the whole packer the way that Pieous in Austin does. The pastrami I had there is the gold standard for what I'm shooting for and these pictures look amazing. I'd appreciate anything you can share on the process and the final results.

Smoked pastrami recipe that is sure to impress your guests (12)

James Rojas

6 years ago

Reading through your article you mentioned taking the brisket to 185 internal temperature. Did you find that it was as moist and juicy as you would get taking a normal brisket to the range of 195 - 205 that many take theirs to before resting? I've never had a brisket ready at 185 IT but I wasn';t dealing with one that had been brined either. I know that Pieous adds one additional step to their pastrami cook in the form of a C-Vap unit, but I don't think that's necessary.

How many times have you cooked with this recipe now?

Smoked pastrami recipe that is sure to impress your guests (13)

Bryan Gooding

6 years ago

I have been cooking briskets for years and have cooked three of these pastrami's. I believe the brine is the difference in the cooking temperature. I know in the case of smoking chicken that cooking to 168f and resting, I end up with tons of moisture in a fully cooked breast. I would assume the same with the pastrami, I think the pictures show a lot of juiciness in the flat I used (flats being notorious for turning dry). I have not done a complete brisket pastrami (point and flat) and would assume there would be an adjustment. Also since I am on an island and trying to stay local in my sources, the briskets here tend to run small and can be lean since they are organic. You read the latest article posted on Aaron Franklin and he's even mentioning barometric pressure? All these things can affect the quality. Experiment!

Smoked pastrami recipe that is sure to impress your guests (14)

James

6 years ago

I am going to use your amazing article as a starting point for my own journey and keep you up to date on my shenanigans. I'm going to be cooking the entire packer on a Fast Eddy pellet smoker with a blend of mesquite, pecan and oak. I'll probably brine for about 3 weeks on my first attempt. I'll definitely keep you in the loop.

I cook lots of briskets but the wonderful pastrami I had at Pieous spoke to me in a special way. I knew after that experience that this was something I wanted to learn to cook.

I love the picture on this article and it does look very moist with great bark and that signature rosy color. If you have other photos I'd love to see them.

Smoked pastrami recipe that is sure to impress your guests (15)

Rueben E Moberly

5 years ago

Do you wrap at any point?

Smoked pastrami recipe that is sure to impress your guests (2024)

FAQs

What kind of wood do you use to smoke pastrami? ›

For wood, you want to use something mild. While the smoke flavor is going to add to the quality of the pastrami, you do not want to overpower the flavor with a strong wood like hickory or mesquite. A popular wood to use when making pastrami is maple. We also like to use woods like apple, cherry, or grape.

What is the best cut of meat for pastrami? ›

Pastrami is made with point brisket, which contains more marbling and fat. Pastrami can also be made with other cuts of beef, such as deckle (a lean shoulder cut) or navel (aka beef belly, which comes from the plate, a juicy section just below the ribs).

How long should I smoke my pastrami? ›

Place the pastrami directly on the grill grates, spiced side up. Insert the probe into the thickest part of the brisket. Close the lid and smoke until the internal temperature reaches 160°F, 3-4 hours. Remove the smoked pastrami from the grill and tightly wrap in foil.

Do you smoke pastrami fat side up or down? ›

On the other hand, you can retain the flavor from your seasoning when the fat side faces down. This will also protect the meat from the direct heat underneath it. Smoking meat this way will also result in less surface drying and make it more tender.

What is the difference between smoked brisket and pastrami? ›

But some hard differences stand out: Pastrami is usually made with dense, fatty navel while smoked meat comes from leaner, stringier brisket. Pastrami is usually brined while smoked meat is dry rubbed with curing salt.

Is pastrami just smoked corned beef? ›

The main difference between corned beef and pastrami is the way they're cut and processed. Plus, after cutting and curing, corned beef is boiled, whereas pastrami is smoked and steamed. Whether you have a taste for Corned Beef or Pastrami, you will find an expansive list of items on the Brent's Deli menu.

What kind of cheese goes with pastrami? ›

Cheese: Not all pastrami sandwiches have cheese, but those that do use Swiss cheese. In a pinch, provolone cheese works well, too. Feel free to use any other white mild cheese you love for a slightly different taste. Mustard: For a slightly spicy kick, use dijon mustard for the sauce.

What part of cow is pastrami? ›

Corned beef is made from brisket, which comes from the lower chest of the cow; pastrami is either made from a cut called the deckle, a lean, wide, firm shoulder cut, or the navel, a smaller and juicier section right below the ribs. These days, you may also see pastrami made from brisket.

What animal is pastrami from? ›

Pastrami (Romanian: pastramă) is a food originating from Romania usually made from beef brisket. Later recipes use lamb, pork, chicken or turkey. The raw meat is brined, partially dried, seasoned with herbs and spices, then smoked and steamed.

Why does pastrami turn GREY? ›

Exposure to light and oxygen causes oxidation to take place, which causes the breaking down of color pigments formed during the curing process. Chemicals in the cure and oxygen, as well as energy from ultraviolet and visible light, contribute to both the chemical breakdown and microbial spoilage of the product.

How do you know when pastrami is done? ›

Smoke the brisket for 4-5 hours or until the internal temperature reaches 160-165 degrees. At this point traditional Pastrami is steamed until it's tender (that's deli style Pastrami); I'm going for more BBQ style Pastrami. Wrap it in Pink Butcher Paper and place back on the pit.

Why does pastrami turn green? ›

There are various pigments in meat compounds that can give it an iridescent or greenish cast when exposed to heat and processing. According to overseas food safety authorities, iridescence does not represent decreased quality or safety of the meat.

How do you keep pastrami moist? ›

Most of these methods involve using water as a moisture agent, so make sure to drain the Pastrami well after heating to avoid soaking the bread. Method #1: Place the Pastrami in a piece of heavy duty foil, add a little water, and fold it over and seal it well.

Do you trim brisket for pastrami? ›

Trim the brisket flat of any remaining fat. Combine water, sugar and salt in a small pan and place over low heat. Stir until sugar and salt have dissolved, then allow mix to cool. Once cooled, add in curing salt and spices.

What part of the brisket is best for pastrami? ›

For pastrami, the flat section of the brisket is favored by many because it makes nice even slices for sandwiches, but I prefer the point section of the brisket because it is fattier, richer, and more tender.

What wood to smoke corned beef? ›

Some of the best wood types for smoking corned beef are cherry, apple, hickory, or mesquite. The fruit woods -- cherry and apple -- will lend a sweet, subtle smoke flavor. Hickory and mesquite are stronger flavored woods.

What wood is best for smoking meat? ›

What is the Best Wood for Smoking Meat?
  • Oak. Oak is the quintessential go-to for smoking meat. ...
  • Hickory. The most versatile choice as it can be used to smoke wood in many ways. ...
  • Maple. One of the most subtle smoking wood, it will impart a more subtle smoke flavor. ...
  • Mesquite. ...
  • Pecan. ...
  • Apple. ...
  • Alder. ...
  • Cherry.

What's the best wood for smoking beef? ›

Cherry wood is ideal for barbecuing pork and beef and gives a vibrant mahogany color to the meat. You can balance cherry wood by mixing it with hickory, oak, or pecan.

Which wood is best for smoking brisket? ›

Oak: The Time-Tested Favorite

Renowned for its versatility and balanced flavor profile, oak wood is a reliable choice for smoking brisket to perfection. The subtle yet pervasive smokiness of oak adds depth to the brisket's taste without overpowering its natural flavors.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Lilliana Bartoletti

Last Updated:

Views: 6406

Rating: 4.2 / 5 (53 voted)

Reviews: 84% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Lilliana Bartoletti

Birthday: 1999-11-18

Address: 58866 Tricia Spurs, North Melvinberg, HI 91346-3774

Phone: +50616620367928

Job: Real-Estate Liaison

Hobby: Graffiti, Astronomy, Handball, Magic, Origami, Fashion, Foreign language learning

Introduction: My name is Lilliana Bartoletti, I am a adventurous, pleasant, shiny, beautiful, handsome, zealous, tasty person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.